• Sign up
  • ‎What is Shvoong?‎
  • Sign In
    Sign In
    Remember my username Forgot your password?

Summaries and Short Reviews

.

Shvoong Home>Arts & Humanities>History>Judas Iscariot- Questions Should Be Asked Summary

.

Judas Iscariot- Questions Should Be Asked

Article Summary by: Urbane    

Original Author: Karmit
This abstract was translated from יהודה איש קריות

This is how Christianity tells the famous story of the betrayal since old times to today: around

30 AD the divine presence has began to spread its cover over the city scorched within its walls. Just hours before the commencement of Passover, the narrow streets of Jerusalem are full of merchants’ carts and their merchandise, Jews are running around here and there making the last minute purchases for the holiday. The preparations before the gathering for the Passover meal and the holy temple with its shining light of gold is touching the entire city.At the bottom of the mountain that’s across the eastern gates of the city (the gates of mercy) in a garden of greening fruit and olive trees, which is called the garden of oils, where Jeshua (Jesus) the Jew used to seclude with his students, the heads of the priests, the elders and their guards armed with spears began to approach. Judas, Jesus’s favourite student was leading them. They got closer to Jesus who was expecting them. Judas Iscariot approaches his teacher and kisses him. Jesus calls to him, “with a kiss you will give me in, Judas?” all the while that the guards’ handcuffs are wrapped around his body and he is delivered to the Romans. After seeing the Jesus is handed over to the Roman representative and that his punishment is crucifixion, he is filled with guilt and regret. He returns the bribe money that he received to the priests, who refused to take it, and kills himself by hanging.The kiss of betrayal and Judas Iscariot have become the archetype of the Jewish people: treacherous, greedy, cunning and making deals with the devil. Due to this puzzling turn of events, the hatred of the Jews has established itself among the Christians for many generations. All of them were carrying a collective punishment for the crucifixion of Christ- Jesus, the Christian messiah.
But was there really a betrayal?What was Judas’s interest in betraying his teacher whom he admired? Was he disappointed with his message? Was he hoping for the salvation that Jesus promised and when that didn’t happed he expressed his disappointment by giving him in? Is that logical that in the evening of the holiday, a large crowd would gather and walk to the walls of the city just to watch the surrendering of another spiritual preacher among many? Was Judas Iscariot trying to save the Jewish people from the punishments of the Roman government , which reacted ruthlessly to any unions that threatened the governing peace, and by giving in Jesus he actually prevented violence against his people? And if indeed Jesus was so known and recognized at the gates of the city and the whole land, why was there a need to mark him to his capturers with a kiss? And if Judas was so greedy, why then he tried to return the bribe money?The Christian gospels tell that Jesus knew about his future fate. During the last supper he announced to his students that one of them was going to hand him over and that the traitor shall be damned till his dying day... Judas asks, “ Am I the man?” and Jesus answers- the one I will pass the bread to is the one who will give me in... and he passes the bread to Judas Iscariot.According the Christian writings Judas Iscariot goes on with his scheme when the devil takes over him and makes him do the horrible betrayal.2000 years of pogroms, oppression and  slaughter were the fate of the European Jews. 2000 years Christians were pointing a finger at Judas Iscariot and the Jewish people making it their  fault for surrendering Jesus and the crucifixion. Judas’s cunning face which was painted with feelings of immense hatred in the Christian belief, was the ugly, dark skinned face with the eagle-like nose in the Nazi propaganda. The money that he allegedly received for handing in Jesus was used to create the Jews’ reputation for greediness and love of money. 
-Article continues in the comments section-


Published: May 14, 2008
Please Rate this Review : 1 2 3 4 5

Comments & Reviews about Judas Iscariot- Questions Should Be Asked

Showing 8 out of 8   Add your comment
  1. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    1

    Urbane

    article continued 01

    The schemes that he allegedly made with the priests and the elders to surrender his teacher were used to portray the Jews as cunning and sneaky. His treacherous kiss, the symbol of love and affection towards Jesus, was used to paint the Jewish people as not trustworthy and disloyal.

  2. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    2

    Urbane

    article continued 02

    All the gospels point out the fact that Jesus had known about his fate and even rushed him to do his task in delivering him to the Romans, and if so, is it possible that Judas was a victim in his own tragedy by taking a part in God’s plan?

  3. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    3

    Urbane

    article continued 03

    Was it possible that Judas Iscariot did not have the freedom of choice and he just went along with the predestined turn of events that were ordered from the heavens, and only when his job was done he understood the proportion of the tragedy and chose to end his life?

  4. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    4

    Urbane

    article continued 04

    And what would have happened if the image of Judas Iscariot was never created? How would have Jesus gone to his death, and would his followers still succeeded in making him a messiah who with his death atoned the sins of all of humanity?

  5. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    5

    Urbane

    article continued 05

    With his death, did he not give atonement to Judas Iscariot as well? Did the Christians forget that Jesus himself lived, acted and died as a Jew? And what would have been the story of Jesus and Christianity without Judas Iscariot?

  6. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    6

    Urbane

    why Judas

    The real question to ask here, assuming that Judas Iscariot was indeed weak and in fault, evil, made a deal with the devil and so on...- why was this individual who had made a mistake was chosen to represent a whole nation?

  7. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    7

    Urbane

    Jesus was a jew

    And since Jesus was indeed a Jew, his family and friends were Jews and he never preached for a new religion, wouldn’t hating all Jews mean hating Jesus himself and all who was close to him?

  8. 0 Ratings Wednesday, May 14, 2008
    8

    Urbane

    why the hatred

    And why are generations of people being hated for something that was done thousands of years ago- the Jews do not hate the grand children of the Nazis, because they cannot be responsible for something that happened before they were even born.

Bookmark & share this post

.